For many months as Biden considered nearly a dozen women for the ticket, California Sen. Kamala Harris seemed like the most natural fit because of her resume, her visibility supporting the Black Lives Matter protests, and her championing of legislation to curb police brutality. But over the past week, long-held uneasiness among some close Biden allies about Harris’ ambition and her attack on Biden during a June 2019 debate broke into the open.
Then this weekend, it was California Rep. Karen Bass’ turn in the hot seat, as the Trump campaign highlighted her trips to Cuba as a young activist and questioned whether Biden would “put Castro-loving Communist Karen Bass a heartbeat away from the presidency” — underscoring the potential risks for Biden in choosing a politician who is largely unknown as the other side races to define them.
Though vice presidential picks have rarely had a major effect on the outcome of an election, Biden’s pick has taken on an outsized importance this year — not only because of voters’ concerns about his age, but also because in the midst of a pandemic and a painful recession, his team knows he must heed the first rule of vice presidential politics by picking a loyal partner who does no harm.
The spectacle of the vice presidential vetting process breaking into public view illustrated the difficulty of the decision facing Biden as he narrows his choice, as well as the behind-the-scenes maneuvering by the potential hopefuls and those who would vie to replace them in their current roles. (The current parlor game in California political circles, for example, is guessing who Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom might appoint to an open US Senate seat if Harris vacates hers.)
Though Biden’s team has kept the process secret, the former vice president made it clear from the beginning that he would pick a woman, and his team has vetted Bass, Harris and former Obama national security adviser Susan Rice — who are widely viewed as top contenders — as well as Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren, Illinois Sen. Tammy Duckworth and Florida Rep. Val Demings. Others under consideration include Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms and Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer.
‘There will be a resistance to your ambition’
For many months, it was no secret that some of Biden’s allies were still galled by Harris’ attack on Biden during the 2019 debate in Miami, where she called out Biden’s opposition to busing decades earlier as a young Delaware senator and his boasts that he had found a way to work with segregationist senators (comments she said she found hurtful).
Her knockout punch in Miami gave her a fleeting boost in the polls, but became a potential strike against her. Biden looked stunned and hurt in that moment, in part because the two Democrats had been longtime allies and because Harris had been close with his late son Beau Biden, when they had served as attorneys general at the same time, she from California and he from Delaware.
Though Harris ultimately ended her presidential bid before the voting began, the sting of that moment has persisted. A Politico story last Monday quoted former Connecticut Sen. Chris Dodd, a member of Biden’s vice presidential vetting team, telling a donor that Harris showed “no remorse” for her attempted takedown of Biden in that debate.
The need to defend her was apparently so top of mind for Biden that he was photographed at a press conference Tuesday holding a notecard with talking points about Harris that included: “do not hold grudges,” “talented” and “great help to campaign” — setting off a fresh round of speculation that Harris would be his choice.
The public airing of that grievance — as well as widely circulated comments from some Biden backers that Harris is too ambitious and might be too focused on her own designs for the White House — led to pushback from her allies this past week and from Harris herself on Friday.
Addressing the accusation of ambition, which has come up as a strike against Harris at many other points during her political career, the California Democrat implicitly invoked sexism when she told the online audience for the Black Women Lead 2020 conference that “there will be a resistance to your ambition. There will be people who say to you: ‘You are out of your lane.’ … Don’t you let that burden you.”
Low-profile contender suddenly in the spotlight
On Friday and Saturday, Biden’s Republican opponents unearthed the opposition research against Bass, who has strong support from both Democratic Party leadership and rank-and-file members after her years of experience in Congress, as chair of the Congressional Black Caucus, and as former Speaker of the California Assembly. (She was the first Black woman in history to serve in that role).
CNN’s MJ Lee, Jeff Zeleny and Jasmine Wright reported last week that Bass, a low-profile contender who is widely admired by her peers as a skilled legislator, has gained real traction in the late stage of the vice presidential search. She recently led a police reform bill through House that united all the Democrats, and CNN has reported that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi told Biden’s team not to overlook her.
In anticipation of Biden’s announcement of his pick as early as next week, the Trump campaign spent the weekend highlighting past comments about Cuba and Fidel Castro by Bass, who first went to Cuba in 1973 as a young activist to build houses with a group known as the Venceremos Brigade. She told The Atlantic in a recent interview that she went to Cuba eight times during the 1970s, and returned about that many times in later years as her focus shifted to legislating.
Bass told the Sacramento Bee Editorial Board in a recent interview that she was “a young radical” in those early years. She compared her experience to that of the far-left protesters filling the streets now in demonstrations against police brutality toward Black people.
“Those young people that are out saying ‘defund the police’? That was me,” she told The Sacramento Bee editorial board. “My entire life has been driven by fighting for social and economic justice. That has been the guiding post that has led me to do a lot of different things.”
But Republicans have focused on Bass’ description of Castro when he died in 2016. She expressed her condolences to the Cuban people and Castro’s family: “The passing of the Comandante en Jefe is a great loss to the people of Cuba,” Bass said in her statement. “I hope together, our two nations will continue on the new path of support and collaboration with one another, and continue in the new direction of diplomacy.”
She told The Atlantic in that recent interview she was trying to translate “commander in chief” and added, “If I had to make that statement over again, I wouldn’t use those words.”
Still, the Trump campaign is already using the Bass-Cuba connection to try to inflict damage on Biden in Florida, a crucial battleground state with a large and influential Cuban population.
On a Trump campaign press call Saturday, Florida Republican Sen. Marco Rubio said that if Bass became vice president, she would be “the highest-ranking Castro sympathizer in the history of the United States government. And it couldn’t come at a worst time, when both regimes in Venezuela and in Havana are teetering on the brink of real collapse.”
Bass, who is 66, was also forced to defend her faith Saturday on Twitter — noting that she “proudly” worships at First New Christian Fellowship Baptist Church in South LA — after the conservative outlet, the Daily Caller, resurfaced a video of her speaking at a 2010 opening of a Church of Scientology in Los Angeles.
The California congresswoman explained on Twitter that she attended the opening of the Scientology building because it was in her congressional district. In the remarks at the opening, she said she found an “area of agreement in their beliefs” that “all people, of whatever, race, color, or creed are created with equal rights.”
She acknowledged that in the decade since that speech, “published first-hand accounts in books, interviews and documentaries have exposed this group” and that “everyone is now aware of the allegations against Scientology.”
The debate over the pros and cons of each potential vice presidential contender will only get more intense in the next week. Democrats, for example, are debating whether Demings can withstand the debate over her three-year tenure as chief of the Orlando Police Department — if it could blunt criticism that Biden is too soft on crime or would more likely alienate Black Lives Matter activists who say she should have done more to change the system from within.
Duckworth, an Iraq veteran and Purple Heart recipient, could face pushback from the left-wing of the Democratic Party that she is too centrist at a time when Biden is trying to unite the party following his defeat of Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders in the primary. Bottoms and Whitmer are both in key governing positions in states that have been ravaged by coronavirus, putting them in a tenuous and vulnerable position if they were to suddenly switch gears and focus on the presidential race.
The Biden campaign is making history by vetting what is the largest and most diverse field of potential female vice presidential candidates ever. And in a deeply polarizing election cycle, as many Americans fight for their economic and physical survival, this group is likely to face more intense scrutiny than any group that has come before them in this final stretch.